When a crane starts to age, buying a new one is not the only option. Through modernization, we can improve the safety, reliability and cost-efficiency of an older overhead crane, for example, and extend its service life. Modernizations can often be carried out without long production shutdowns.

In practice, a modernization can mean a single upgrade or replacement of almost an entire crane. The crane’s steel structure often still has service life left, and it is worth utilizing if it makes sense cost-wise. The steel structure typically outlasts the other components of the crane.

– Typical modernizations include replacing the entire electrical system, the hoist trolleys or the travelling machinery. At their most extensive, the result is practically a new crane built around the old structure, says Project Manager Renny Räikkönen.

Our experts always help assess the big picture so that the outcome is the best possible for the customer in terms of both features and costs.

Safer and smoother everyday operations

Safe working around cranes comes up constantly in our discussions with customers. It is worth noting that the safety features of a new crane can also be added to an older crane using brand-independent solutions.

These include overload protection, working area limits and protected areas, sway control, warning sounds and lights, and motion monitoring between cranes in tandem operation. Additional sensors make it possible to detect faults proactively. On the operating side, typical upgrades include replacing inverters, converting contactor-controlled drives to inverter control, replacing travelling machinery and brakes, energy regeneration, and radio controls.

– New radio controls can show the operator information such as fault codes, load data, hook height and travel speed. In addition, speed or capacity can be limited according to the operating situation, Räikkönen explains.

You can also start small. LED lighting, for example, is an easy upgrade that improves safety, especially when working with outdoor cranes during the dark season.

All at once or in phases – on the customer’s schedule

Cranes are often critical equipment for the customer’s production, and every additional maintenance break or shutdown comes at a cost. However, it is not always necessary or sensible to do everything at once. A modernization can be carried out in a few different ways:

Light solution: the crane’s service life is extended for a limited period through maintenance and individual upgrades.
Modular solution: upgrades are planned in advance as packages and carried out over several years.
Complete solution: all planned modernizations are carried out at once.

Many customers schedule the different modules for consecutive summer shutdowns, for example. This spreads the investment evenly and predictably. Some of the work can also be done while production is running.

– We test and pre-commission our solutions as far as possible before installation, so that crane downtime and commissioning are kept as short as possible, Räikkönen says.

Modernization or a new crane?

Customers are often looking for an identical replacement part for a component that has failed. The role of our experts is to look at the big picture together with the customer and assess what makes the most sense in the long term.

– Individual spare parts for older cranes can be disproportionately expensive compared with, for example, replacing the entire hoist trolley or overhead crane, Räikkönen notes.

If the cost of a modernization is around 70–80 percent of the price of new equipment, it is worth analyzing the costs of the alternatives over the longer term. What is the condition of the overhead crane’s steel structure, for example? How many years will the modernization extend its service life?

– Modernization should not be postponed until the equipment starts to fail. Depending on how the crane is used, it is worth reviewing the need annually with a view up to 10 years ahead, Räikkönen reminds.

For reliable crane operation, it is good to keep in mind that some crane components are discontinued as manufacturers replace them with newer products. As a result, new and old products may not be compatible with other components and may require a larger change to the system. Production downtime can become unreasonably long if this is not taken into account early enough in planning.

– We never want to sell anything unnecessary. Our recommendations are always based on the requirements of the lifting equipment, standards and measured data, Räikkönen says.

Photos: Janne Pappila / JTP-Media Oy